Recruitment ▾

People in transition

Outplacement services

Current jobs

Perth candidates: lawyers, accountants and tech talent.

Character-focused recruitment

Request talent

Outsourced HR

Consulting

Marvin Scout ▾

Analytics based

The Scout Survey shows how people perform: their values, communication, affinities and engagement factors.

Proven insights for your team

Engage your team and achieve results.

Order online

About ▾

Talk to us

+61 8 6377 7606

hello@marvinhr.com

Mon to Fri, 9:00am to 5:00pm

“We highly recommend them for your next recruitment.”

Paul Andrew, Chief Executive, Catholic Homes

Read testimonials

Supermarket Giants Face $1 Billion Underpayment Bill

Marvin Scout Header Image

FEDERAL COURT RULING

  • Federal Court ruled on 5 September 2025 that Coles and Woolworths underpaid nearly 30,000 salaried managers
  • Companies failed to keep accurate employment records and improperly used “set-off” arrangements³
  • Justice Nye Perram found employers must pay entitlements each pay period, not annually⁴

FINANCIAL IMPACT

  • Combined liability could exceed $1 billion between both retailers⁵
  • Woolworths estimates additional $180-330 million remediation costs, plus $140-200 million in interest⁶
  • Coles projects $150-250 million in further payments⁷
  • Woolworths already repaid $330 million; Coles paid $31 million⁸

INDUSTRY IMPLICATIONS

  • Australian Retailers Association calls decision “alarming” with widespread compliance burdens⁹
  • Employment experts warn of broader ramifications across Australian business community¹⁰
  • Fair Work Ombudsman Anna Booth describes ruling as “important decision”

NEXT STEPS

  •  Further hearing scheduled for late October 2025
  • Companies reviewing 200-page “complex” judgement
  • Fair Work seeking court orders for penalties and remediation

Key Employer Actions Required:

□ Review existing set-off clauses – Employers need to audit their current arrangements to ensure proper drafting and implementation

□ Assess compliance risks – The ruling highlights substantial risks for employers whose set-off clauses are either poorly implemented or don’t comply with modern award requirements

□ Strengthen record-keeping practices – Employers shouldn’t rely solely on set-off arrangements and employee timesheets to meet their legal record-keeping obligations


Sources: ¹ SBS News ² Inside Retail ³ HR Leader ⁴ The Conversation ⁵ Inside FMCG ⁶ Capital Brief ⁷ Drinks Digest ⁸ AInvest ⁹ ABC ¹⁰ The Conversation

Related posts

INSIGHTS NEWSLETTER

RECENT POSTS

×